Center Hank Fraley, who was in the huddle, twice told Cataldi the next day McNabb was "almost puking," and later receiver Freddie Mitchell, who was also in the huddle, spoke about McNabb having "some kind of complication" involving "breathing." However, only McNabb and Daunte Culpepper went on to have successful careers in the NFL; Tim Couch struggled with the Cleveland Browns and officially retired in 2007 after being cut by the J… There is nothing wrong with that, young man, great job. McNabb was the second of five quarterbacks selected in the first 12 picks of a quarterback-rich class that was at that point considered the best quarterback draft since the famous class of 1983. It's still not clear if anyone ever saw any vomit hit the field.The subject came up because during a FoxSports broadcast Thursday night, McNabb commented about a player vomiting by saying, to laughter in the booth, "Well, the fact is that I've thrown up on the field a couple of times. "Jon Ritchie is now the second ex-Eagle to say he saw Donovan McNabb puke at the 2005 Super Bowl.Did Ritchie see actual upchucking during the game?Eagles news in your inbox year-round"Some guys have those nervous stomachs," Ritchie said.Here's hoping the truth, whatever it is, eventually spills out.Once again, however, a WIP personality failed to get crucial details. Running back Brian Westbrook said, ""He was coughing a little, but he didn't seem sick. Whether or not Donovan McNabb threw up in the Super Bowl is on the list of the great unsolved mysteries in the history of sport ,at least in Philadelphia. No one at the game saw him throw up. The WIP crew took that to be an admission about the Super Bowl, but it could also have been a facetious reference to how he's been mocked.The huddle theory is still at a loss for evidence. McNabb was drafted in the first round with the second overall pick by the Eagles, behind first pick Tim Couch, in the 1999 NFL Draft. Throw up and then throw a touchdown." Did McNabb Actually Throw Up in Super Bowl XXXIX?
Eagles quarterback Donovan McNabb did not throw up in the fourth quarter of Super Bowl XXXIX. “He’s been there and done it,” Reid told reporters on why McNabb was invited to speak. Video of the Super Bowl shows the huddle in question and no vomit hits the field. This urban legend has taken on a life of its own over the years, largely fueled by Freddie Mitchell’s biased timeline of events. It was good hearing from him.”The play where McNabb is accused of vomiting is the first point of contention in any Super Bowl XXXIX timeline. And now, there is … "Sheppard said the puking he saw from the sidelines was "subtle," but host Rob Charry failed to ask what that meant. Was he saying McNabb had dry heaves? Throw up and then throw a touchdown." Most of the “puke truthers” have called out a drive with about three minutes to play in the fourth quarter.Meanwhile, McNabb has vehemently denied vomiting in the biggest game of his life. "It looked that way," the former fullback said on SportsRadio 94 WIP this morning.McNabb also said, "I love it.